Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Great place for a sunset! Music was good but a little loud. Drinks were tasty although a little weak (not necessarily a bad thing). Food was fine. We had the smash burger and pretzels with cheese and side salad. It was a fun evening.

Love the views, great outdoor seating. Peel and eat shrimp, conch fritters and and the grouper sandwich were all very tasty. Been here a few times before, youcan't go wrong with this place. Yummy

Overall: 4/5 Food: 4/5 Service: 5/5 Attractive point: Magnificent view during sunset This place is well known for its beautiful view during sunset so there was already some people waiting when we arrived there around 6 pm in Tuesday. I personally think the sunset view is worth waiting if the waiting is expected to be less than 40 mins. Options are bar / table (some are right next to the beach) / beach seats and if you wish to get a beach table, you might have to wait longer. Live performance was going on when we arrived. Not sure if that’s everyday event, but it added more vibe to entire place. Service was awesome, our server deserved her 5 stars. We tried Conch fritters, Key lime pie, and mahi fish sandwich. Foods were great and well cooked, but my partner thinks that the conches were a little bit too chewy. Quality-price ratio was not optimal, but considering the location, it wasn’t that bad compared to other over-priced restaurant.

Casual dining with great views! Great place to grab a quick bite and soak up some sun or let the fresh ocean breeze carry away all your worries. Went with a group for lunch on our way back to Miami after being in Key West for a long weekend. Can’t say enough good things about the atmosphere and service! Our waitress was phenomenal. You can tell the people that work here are just happy. Our group got a couple of cocktails which were good and a smattering of apps from the menu to munch on. The conch fritters were similar to a hush puppy for those not familiar. Overall mild but satisfies the desire for a fried snack. The beer cheese that came with the pretzel was a big hit for the group. The onion rings were fried well and not a piece left behind. As for me, I challenged myself to get vegan food items and was very successful. I ordered two sides off the menu that I thought would be filling and hold me over, the rice and beans. I had rice and beans a bunch throughout the keys and it’s amazing how flavorful such a simple dish can be. The rice a Lorelei was a little hard either from being slightly underdone or just sitting a while. And the beans were decent. I wasn’t unhappy and it certainly was filling, but not the best I had while in the Keys. I also ordered off menu and our waitress hooked me up with chips and guac. The fresh potato chips were quite good and the guac was a welcomed attendee to the party. Lots of flavor. Overall, this place is a good stop if you’re visiting or just passing through on your way to Miami or Key West. Again, the service is top notch and you’re going to leave feeling well taken care of!

Gorgeous place for sunset. Go to the way back bar. Expect to wait for drinks. Dry rub chicken wings at happy hour were decent. Haven't had a meal here. To me, it's a sunset outdoor drink place. But there are tons of tables and on a Sunday around 530pm , last week of February, I heard 40 minute wait

This place is my happy place. Myself & family have been fortunate enough to frequent the Lorelei restaurant and its a family favorite from the morning mimosas too the dangerously delicious Bushwacker! There's plenty to drink. I love the shrimp & grits (one of the only food pictures iv taken) of course the conch,stone crab,lobster Mac and cheese right down to the chicken quesdillia. Its all good. The service is top notch and you feel pampered in paradise through out your experience.there usually is a band or entertainment like magic shows from a local favorite but the big draw is the sunsets if you have a tropical sunset fantasy this is the place to make it happen. I plan to get married here in the near future. (Who wouldn't want to get hitched in the fishing capital of the world) sure its pricey but worth every dime. If you make it down this far on highway #1 stop at the Lorelei restaurant and tiki bar in IslaMorada otw to key west you will have a new happy place.

I had the tuna nachos. They were ok. The atmosphere was pleasant. There were alot of tables. Many on the sand. Inside the bar area was full. Mostly local folks. One older gal came through the restaurant in a thong bikini.. Geez... I can see how this is a hangout within the yacht club for the local yachties. All the food that was brought out looked very yummy. Id definitely go back for the food and beautiful view. My waitress was so friendly and the service was top notch. And the hotel sauce! Great flavor. Didn't overpower, but added a mild kick.

Got a recommendation from an old man at the park up the street that this place was chill with great food. Glad I heeded his advice. My family of 3 came at about 5pm and was immediately seated. Food was great and the service was fast. Recommend trying their Key lime colada and conch fritters! Outside view is relaxed and scenic by the water. Live music too!